Ranked-choice voting strategies could decide which Democratic and Republican candidates win the June 9 primaries.
By MATT JUNKER | The Maine Monitor
At the Maine State House on Monday, Republican candidate for governor David Jones showed voters how he would rank himself and other GOP contenders in a crowded primary election. But there was a notable absence from his ballot choices.
_____
Using Maine’s ranked-choice voting system, Jones selected himself first — followed by five of the six other active candidates in the race to represent Republicans in the general election for Maine governor. Absent from that descending list of Jones’ preferred candidates was Bobby Charles, who has consistently led the GOP field in recent polling and repeatedly drawn criticism from Jones.
“Trust matters, and at this point, Robert Charles has not earned mine,” said Jones, a real estate businessman who has knocked former U.S. State Department official and lobbyist Charles for not attending all of the debates during the Republican primary.
Jones’ public unveiling of his ballot is just one example of how feuds and alliances have come to define the packed fields in both the Republican and Democratic primaries to help choose Maine’s next governor.
And with Maine’s use of ranked-choice voting, at least in these June 9 primaries, those fault lines could very well decide the final results as candidates from both parties look to cobble together enough support to reach more than 50 percent of the votes at some point in the ranked-choice tabulation.
Unlike the more typical “first past the post” voting system, in which voters select one candidate and whoever gets the most votes wins whether or not they get a majority, ranked-choice voting allows voters to rank all candidates by preference and can involve multiple rounds of tabulation until one candidate gets more than 50 percent of the votes.
RELATED | Ranked-choice voting explained
The GOP primary has included some level of acrimony for several months, largely between frontrunner Charles and other candidates. For much of the campaign, discord hasn’t been as visible among the five Democratic candidates for governor, with many often highlighting their policy similarities, but as the June 9 primary approaches they too have seen prominent disagreements and partnerships take form.
Those alliances and feuds haven’t just factored into what candidates are saying about each other on the campaign trail. Candidates are also making direct appeals to voters based on those relationships, not only telling people to vote for them, but also giving them suggestions on how to rank the other candidates as well. If followed, those instructions could determine how both primary elections shake out.
The nominees from each party will face state Sen. Rick Bennett, who is running as an independent and recently qualified for the November ballot.
_____
Republican rancor
Charles has not only routinely found his way to the forefront in GOP primary field polling, he has also frequently been at the center of intra-party squabbles. When Jones criticized him during a March debate in Bangor hosted by the conservative outlet The Maine Wire, Charles framed it as a reflection of his positioning in the race.
“So, this is what it looks like to be the frontrunner,” Charles responded at the time.
It can be lonely at the top, and while Charles’ popularity with potential primary voters has looked solid, he hasn’t exactly been winning any popularity contests among his fellow candidates.
While some of the other GOP candidates have formed alliances and offered suggestions to supporters on which of their opponents to make their second choice in ranked-choice voting, Charles has implored supporters to rank only him “straight across” their ballot in every spot.
Charles’ campaign and others have also traded barbs and accusations about a group of shadowy websites created during the primary to criticize GOP candidates Garrett Mason, Ben Midgley and Charles.
Amid the discord, Jones and fitness industry executive Midgley have formed an alliance and encouraged supporters to rank the other as their second choice. Businessman Robert Wessels, whose campaign hasn’t gained significant traction in the polls, has announced fellow Republican candidate and former health care technology entrepreneur Jonathan Bush as his second choice and became a grassroots regional chair for Bush in May while continuing his own campaign.
Bush, whose campaign sent out a press release on Thursday knocking Charles’ time spent as a lobbyist in Washington, D.C., has also picked up the endorsement of state Sen. James Libby, another candidate listed on the Republican primary ballot. Though voters will still see Libby’s name on that ballot, he ended his gubernatorial campaign earlier this spring after failing to qualify for public financing.
Libby’s exit left seven candidates still actively campaigning for the Republican nomination, and, combined with the use of ranked-choice voting, the complicated web of alliances, endorsements and warnings among this large field could ultimately decide the race.
Not all of the candidates have gotten tangled up in that web. Engineer and entrepreneur Owen McCarthy cited his pledge to run a positive campaign in a video posted Tuesday on Facebook.
“I just had a supporter say, ‘Owen, I decided today that I’m going to vote for you.’ And I asked them why,” McCarthy said. “And they said, ‘While all your competitors are burning each other’s houses down, you’re running on ideas for a better future.’”
_____
_____
Democrats turn up the heat
For much of the primary, the five Democratic candidates for governor were, at least publicly, projecting a uniformly friendly rapport across the board. The general sentiment among the candidates seemed to be: any of them would make a good governor.
But as former Maine Center for Disease Control and Prevention director Dr. Nirav Shah has led the polls, outside groups and money have increasingly entered the fray, and candidate alliances have formed, that veneer of collegiality has worn thin.
Not unlike with Charles in the Republican primary, Shah’s status as the apparent frontrunner has been met with opponents coming together around a concerted ranked-choice voting strategy.
Secretary of State Shenna Bellows, former Speaker of the Maine House Hannah Pingree and former Maine Senate President Troy Jackson have formed an alliance and encouraged their supporters to rank the other two candidates as their second and third choices.
“I’m asking Mainers to rank me first, but also to support these two colleagues with their second and third place votes,” Bellows said in a press release announcing the cross-endorsement. “I helped pass ranked choice voting so you’d have this power. Use it.”
And as alliances have deepened, so too have disagreements.
Shah has seen an influx of support from out-of-state group 314 Action, which works to elect Democrats with science backgrounds. The at least $650,000 that group is spending independently from any of the campaigns in Maine hasn’t just been to support Shah — it has also included swipes at his opponents, including an ad from the outside group that portrayed Jackson as opposing abortion based on past positions and statements, despite his more recent evolution on the issue.
“They’re flooding the airways and putting hundreds of thousands of dollars lying to people about my record on abortion, when I spent the past decade fighting to protect abortion rights,” Jackson said at a Thursday press conference. “And unlike Dr. Shah, I have the votes to back it up.”
A different out-of-state group that supports progressive candidates around the country, the Working Families Party, has committed a nearly $200,000 independent expenditure to support Bellows, Jackson and Pingree over Shah and renewable energy entrepreneur Angus King III.
The group released an ad that criticized Shah on several fronts, including for his time leading the Illinois Department of Public Health and his handling of a deadly Legionnaire’s Disease outbreak before coming to Maine.
Shah authored an op-ed in the Portland Press Herald on Thursday pushing back against the ad and its claims, and saying that he “will not let dark money attack ads define this race.” He similarly accused the dark money ads of injecting lies into the primary race.
King released a statement Friday about the late flurry of attack ads, saying that Maine voters deserve better.
“Some folks have decided their best argument is against someone else rather than for something better,” King said. “I’m not going to join them.”
Shah has also taken the notable step of actively courting second-choice voters in an ad, a nod to the likelihood that this race won’t be settled in just one round. And those subsequent rankings could ultimately decide who represents the Democratic Party in November’s general election for governor.
MORE | Read the full story here: https://themainemonitor.org/alliances-feuds-shape-governor-races/
ABOUT THE AUTHOR | Matt Junker is an elections and government reporter for The Maine Monitor, focusing on the state’s electoral process and decision-making in Augusta. He previously spent more than seven years at the Bangor Daily News, most recently as sports editor after several years working as the paper’s deputy opinion editor.
Contact Matt with questions, concerns or story ideas: matt@themainemonitor.org
NOTE | This story was originally published by The Maine Monitor, a nonprofit and nonpartisan news organization. It is republished here with permission. To get regular coverage from The Monitor, sign up for a free Monitor newsletter here | The Maine Monitor Newsletter
_____
THE BIDDEFORD GAZETTE
“Keeping You Connected to Biddeford”
Editorial Standards & Policies
© 2026 Biddeford Gazette, Inc. All Rights Reserved
BIDDEFORD GAZETTE 